CRITSupplier B
HSE incident record below threshold
LTIFR 0.82 exceeds RFP mandatory ceiling of 0.5. Award blocked pending waiver from Example Buyer HSE board.
HIGHSupplier C
Missing API 17E certification
Supplier C provided DNV-ST-F119 + NORSOK Z-001 only. RFP requires 17E — mandatory compliance gap.
HIGHSupplier B
Retention clause 5%, exceeds 3% cap
Retention 5% of contract is €255k above RFP commercial terms. Renegotiation required before NTP.
HIGHSupplier A
BOM total discrepancy €110k
Quoted €5.8M vs line-item total €5.91M. Vendor to confirm binding total before award.
MEDSupplier A
Delivery exceeds target by 4 weeks
Delivery W52 vs target W48. Float absorbed by installation window but reduces contingency.
MEDSupplier C
Min bend radius 2.7m — above RFP
RFP ceiling 2.5m. Supplier C at 2.7m. Installation spool re-design estimated €60–90k.